20+ year of experience
Trial ready
Personal attention
Arrested. Charged. First court date scheduled. Now you’re staring at a decision: accept the public defender the court offers, or hire a private criminal defense lawyer?
Both are licensed attorneys. Both can represent you in court. But caseloads, resources, availability, and case outcomes often differ dramatically.
This guide explains what a public defender actually does, how private criminal defense attorneys operate differently, and the questions you need to ask yourself before you decide. If you’re facing serious charges, the choice you make in the next 48 hours may determine whether you walk free or spend years in prison.
Call 866-811-4255 for a free case evaluation. We’ll tell you honestly whether hiring a private attorney makes sense for your situation.
The Sixth Amendment guarantees you the right to an attorney if you’re charged with a crime. That right applies whether you can afford a lawyer or not.
If you cannot afford to hire a private criminal defense attorney, the court will appoint a public defender to represent you. “Cannot afford” is determined by an indigence screening, usually a financial questionnaire at your arraignment. Income thresholds vary by county, but if you’re working full-time at median wages, you likely won’t qualify.
You always have the right to hire a private criminal defense lawyer, even after a public defender has been assigned. You can fire the public defender and retain private counsel at any stage of your case.
If you truly can’t afford either option and don’t qualify for a public defender, the court may still appoint counsel in serious felony cases where jail time is likely.
A public defender is a government-employed attorney who represents criminal defendants who cannot afford to hire private counsel. Public defender offices exist in every California county and at the federal level.
Public defenders are real lawyers. They passed the bar exam. Many have extensive trial experience. Some spent years in private practice before joining a public defender office. Federal public defenders are often among the most skilled criminal attorneys in the country.
But you don’t get to choose your public defender. The office assigns someone based on availability and internal rotation. You get whoever is assigned to courtroom 12 that week.
Caseloads are the core problem. A typical California public defender carries 150 to 200 active cases at any given time. Some carry more. The American Bar Association recommends a maximum of 150 felonies per attorney per year. Many public defenders exceed that in six months.
Funding determines resources. Public defender offices operate on county budgets. Investigators are shared across the entire office. Expert witnesses (forensic analysts, accident reconstruction specialists, medical experts) require supervisor approval and are used sparingly. There’s no budget for extensive pre-trial investigation on a misdemeanor drug possession case.
Public defenders are skilled. The system they work within is broken.
A private criminal defense attorney is hired directly by you or your family. You pay a retainer or flat fee. The attorney works for you, not the government.
Private criminal defense firms range in size from solo practitioners to multi-attorney practices. Many specialize by case type: DUI, drug crimes, violent felonies, white-collar fraud, sex crimes. You can choose an attorney with a track record in your specific charge.
Caseloads vary, but a well-run private practice typically carries 20 to 40 active cases per attorney. That’s one-fifth the load of a public defender. More time per case means more time to investigate, file motions, negotiate, and prepare for trial.
Fee structures differ. Some attorneys charge flat fees for specific case types (common for DUIs). Others require a retainer and bill hourly. Payment plans are often available. You pay for access, attention, and resources.
The attorney you meet during your consultation is usually the attorney who handles your case from arraignment to trial. No handoffs to junior associates you’ve never met.
| Factor | Public Defender | Private Criminal Defense Lawyer |
| Cost | Free if you qualify (indigence test) | Paid (retainer, flat fee, or hourly) |
| Caseload | 150-200+ active cases | 20-40 active cases (varies by firm) |
| Availability | Limited; court schedule dictates meetings | Greater accessibility; direct phone/email access |
| Choice of attorney | Assigned by office; you don’t choose | You choose based on experience, track record, specialization |
| Time per case | Limited due to caseload | More 1-on-1 time for strategy and preparation |
| Resources | Shared investigators; limited expert witness budget | Access to private investigators, expert witnesses, forensic specialists |
| Experience | Varies widely; often extensive trial experience | You can select based on specific case type and trial history |
| Investigation | Reactive; limited pre-filing work | Proactive; can investigate before charges filed |
You genuinely cannot afford a private attorney, and the charges are relatively minor. Misdemeanor shoplifting. First-time DUI with no aggravating factors. Disorderly conduct.
Some public defender offices have strong reputations. Federal public defenders are extremely skilled and well-resourced compared to state-level offices. If you’re facing federal charges and qualify financially, the federal public defender may be an excellent option.
A conflict of interest may prevent private attorneys from taking your case. If multiple defendants are charged in the same case and you’ve already consulted with several private firms, a public defender may be your only realistic option.
For minor charges with limited consequences (no jail time, minimal fines, expungement-eligible), a public defender can competently handle plea negotiations and court appearances.
But if you’re facing serious felony charges, prison time, or life-altering consequences, the limitations of the public defender system become critical.
Unsure which option is right for you?
Serious felony charges. Anything involving potential prison time, a strike under California’s Three Strikes Law, sex offender registration, or deportation consequences if you’re not a U.S. citizen. The stakes are too high to accept a lawyer with 180 other active cases.
Complex cases requiring extensive investigation. Murder. Rape. Armed robbery. Fraud. These cases demand immediate evidence preservation, witness interviews, forensic analysis, and expert testimony. A public defender’s caseload and budget make that nearly impossible.
White-collar crimes. Embezzlement, securities fraud, tax evasion. These cases require attorneys who understand financial records, corporate structures, and federal sentencing guidelines. Specialization matters.
You need immediate legal action before charges are filed. If you’re under investigation but not yet arrested, a private attorney can intervene early, contact prosecutors, present exculpatory evidence, and potentially prevent charges from being filed at all. Public defenders are not assigned until you’re formally charged.
You can afford the investment in your defense. Payment plans are common. Some firms accept credit cards, family loans, or property liens. If you can access funds without bankrupting yourself, the question becomes: what is your freedom worth?
Time-sensitive situations. Bail hearings, restraining order violations, probation violations. Private attorneys can appear in court within hours. Public defenders operate on the court’s calendar.
The numbers are public record. A 2023 study by the ACLU of California found that public defenders in Los Angeles County carried an average of 200 active felony cases per attorney. In some offices, misdemeanor caseloads exceeded 400 cases per attorney per year.
The American Bar Association recommends a maximum of 150 felonies per attorney per year. Most California public defender offices exceed that threshold within six months.
What does that mean for your case? Limited preparation time. A public defender might have 15 minutes to review your file before a court appearance. Investigators are shared across the entire office and prioritized for the most serious cases (murder, rape). Expert witnesses require supervisor approval and compete with budget constraints.
Pressure to resolve cases quickly. Plea bargains move cases off the docket. Trials require days or weeks of preparation. When you’re juggling 200 cases, the system incentivizes quick resolutions, not protracted litigation.
This is not a criticism of individual public defenders. Many are brilliant trial attorneys who care deeply about their clients. But systemic underfunding and overwhelming caseloads make it nearly impossible to provide the same level of attention and resources as a private attorney with 30 active cases.
Immediate case investigation before charges are filed. If you’re under investigation, a private attorney can hire investigators, interview witnesses, collect evidence, and present a defense package to prosecutors before they decide whether to file charges. Public defenders don’t get involved until arraignment.
Private investigators. A dedicated investigator can locate witnesses, obtain surveillance footage, conduct background checks, and reconstruct crime scenes. Public defender offices share investigators across hundreds of cases. Your case competes for time.
Expert witnesses. Forensic analysts who challenge DNA evidence. Accident reconstruction specialists who disprove the prosecution’s version of a car crash. Medical experts who testify about injuries or intoxication. Psychologists who explain mental health factors. Private attorneys can retain experts immediately. Public defenders need supervisor approval and face budget caps.
Pre-filing motions. A private attorney can file motions to suppress evidence, dismiss charges, or compel discovery before trial. These motions require research, briefing, and court hearings. Public defenders prioritize them for the most serious cases.
Dedicated trial preparation. If your case goes to trial, a private attorney can spend weeks preparing: mock cross-examinations, jury selection strategy, opening statements, exhibit preparation. Public defenders often prepare for trial while simultaneously managing 50 other active cases.
Client communication. Direct phone access. Email updates. In-person strategy meetings. Public defenders communicate primarily through brief jail visits or courthouse hallway conversations.
How serious are the charges you’re facing? Misdemeanor or felony? What are the maximum penalties?
What are the real consequences? Jail time, prison, probation, fines, loss of professional license, deportation, sex offender registration, firearm prohibition, impact on child custody?
Can you afford a private attorney? Not easily, but possibly? Payment plans exist. Family may help. Retirement accounts can be tapped (though not ideal). What is your freedom worth in dollar terms?
How complex is your case? Does it require forensic analysis, expert witnesses, or extensive investigation? Or is it a straightforward misdemeanor with minimal factual dispute?
Do you need immediate legal action? Bail reduction hearing, restraining order response, pre-filing intervention? Public defenders are assigned after arraignment. Private attorneys can act today.
Do you have defenses that require investigation? Alibi witnesses who need to be located? Surveillance footage that will be deleted in 30 days? Physical evidence that needs independent testing?
What is your assigned public defender’s caseload and availability? Ask directly. Some public defender offices are better funded and staffed than others.
You have the absolute right to hire a private criminal defense attorney at any time, even after a public defender has been assigned.
Tell the court you’re retaining private counsel. Your new attorney will file a substitution of attorney form. The court will relieve the public defender and recognize your private attorney as counsel of record.
Timing matters. The earlier you switch, the better. Evidence gets lost. Witnesses disappear. Surveillance footage is deleted. Memories fade. If you’re going to hire a private attorney, do it now, not three months into the case.
Some judges will ask why you’re switching if your case is close to trial. The answer is simple: you’ve secured funds to hire private counsel and wish to exercise that right.
Mo Abuershaid is a former Orange County Public Defender. He knows exactly how the system works because he worked within it for years. He left to build a firm that operates differently.
Low caseloads. We don’t take 200 cases per attorney. Your case gets the time it requires.
Immediate investigation. If you call before charges are filed, we start building your defense that day. Investigators locate witnesses. We preserve evidence. We contact prosecutors before they make a filing decision.
Access to investigators and expert witnesses. We retain private investigators on serious cases as a matter of course, not as a last resort. Expert witnesses are brought in when the science or facts require it.
Trial-ready from day one. We prepare every case for trial. That doesn’t mean we don’t negotiate. It means prosecutors know we will try the case if their offer is unreasonable.
The phone is answered. Call 866-811-4255. Nights, weekends, emergencies. We answer.
Free initial consultation. We’ll review your charges, explain your options, and tell you honestly whether hiring a private attorney makes sense for your case. No pressure. No sales pitch.
We do not get paid unless we take your case. And we don’t take cases we can’t give the attention they require.
How much does a private criminal defense attorney cost?
Fees vary by case complexity and attorney experience. Misdemeanors may range from $2,500 to $7,500. Felonies often start at $10,000 and increase based on severity, investigation needs, and trial length. Complex cases (murder, fraud, federal charges) can exceed $50,000. Most firms offer payment plans.
Can I get a payment plan for a private attorney?
Yes. Many criminal defense attorneys offer payment plans, accept credit cards, or work with third-party legal financing companies. Some allow family members to pay on your behalf. Ask during your consultation.
What if I’m assigned a public defender but want to hire my own lawyer?
You can hire a private attorney at any time. Your new lawyer will file a substitution of attorney form with the court. The public defender will be relieved, and your private attorney becomes counsel of record. Do it sooner rather than later.
Will hiring a private attorney guarantee a better outcome?
No attorney can guarantee an outcome. But a private attorney can guarantee more time, more resources, and more attention to your case. Whether that translates to a better result depends on the facts, the evidence, and the law. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
How do I know if a private criminal defense lawyer is worth the cost?
Ask yourself: What am I facing? Prison time? A permanent record? Loss of my career? Deportation? Then ask: What is that worth in dollars? For a misdemeanor shoplifting charge, maybe a public defender is fine. For a felony sexual assault charge that could send you to prison for 15 years, the question answers itself.
Facing criminal charges in Orange County? Call 866-811-4255 for a free consultation. We’ll review your case, explain your options, and help you decide whether hiring a private criminal defense attorney makes sense. The call is free. The advice is honest.
All fields are required. If you need immediate assistance, do not hesitate to call us at (866) 811-4255.
Mohammad Abuershaid, professionally known as Mo Abuershaid, is the founding partner of ALL Trial Lawyers and one of California’s most trusted authorities in dependency law, juvenile dependency cases, CPS defense, and high stakes CPS cases.